Saturday, April 17, 2010

Proof of Substitute

Proof substitute is a phrase that suggests that the speaker has proof, but really there is not proof that is provided. This type of bad argument is always something that comes up when we are arguing with friends and family out of frustration. Other forms of proof substitute are also ridicule and burden of proof. Ridicule is when that the claim that is presented is obviously wrong and perceived as laughable. Shifting the burden of proof is a clever method that a speaker will use when they have not evidence to back up their claim. Instead of the speaker trying to defend their claim with evidence, the speaker tells the person listening to find evidence that their claim is false. Both of these types of bad argument techniques raise the question of asking where the proof is. The purpose for a speaker using this technique is so that they can make themselves sound believable without having any evidence whatsoever.

Appeal to pity

Affirmative action is an intentional bias in selecting a person based on their ethnicity, age, social status, physical disabilities, or military career for selection in things like jobs. A bad argument in favor for affirmative action that appeals to pity would make the person listening to the argument feel bad for the potential people that are picked because of their ethnicity, social class, etc.

Affirmative action should be taken into effect immediately. I think that affirmative action is fair, because it allows minorities to have a fair opportunity in things like employment. Affirmative action helps minority groups that do not get enough voice. Everyone who is a minority should be helped. If affirmative action was never in place than minority groups would never have a chance at a good job or health care and be jobless with no good doctors when they are sick.

There are many holes in this argument with no proof or logic. This argument makes the reader feel bad for the group of people that affirmative action would not be helping if it were not taken into effect and that is the only argument that is presented.

Friday, April 16, 2010

Appeal to Emotion

Appeal to emotion is probably the most often used by every organization that asks for donations to help the needy. While this technique is not an unethical thing to do, it is definitely a fallacy when trying to make an argument correctly. Appeal to emotion offers no evidence but uses appeal similar to fear, pity, or spite. The appeal of emotion that strikes me mostly is probably the appeal to fear. I sometimes catch on TV a car insurance commercial that always shows someone getting into a terrible car accident. Without the proper insurance the person’s car was severely damaged and her day was ruined by a car that rolled down the street and hit her parked car. It shows the lady terrified that her car had been hit. The commercial then proceeds to show how things would have been different if she was a customer of this particular car insurance, which had the effect of her not even missing a minute of her busy day due to the car accident. Companies and organizations effectively use appeal to emotion to get you into whatever they are selling or stand for. It is not necessarily a good way to argue but it does make you think twice about their product.

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Checking for validity with diagrams

Chapter eight discusses how to check validity with diagrams. There are several steps on checking whether an argument is valid. The checks that a diagram must go through are that a collection must be an enclosed area, one premise is entirely related and within another, if there are comparisons to on another then there are similarities that each share, if the two areas do not overlap than there is nothing in common, an a or dot represents that the object is in that collection, and making sure that the argument is valid by checking that there is no way the premises are true and the conclusion false. These checks basically give evidence to an argument by using diagrams. An example given in the book is that all animals that bark are mammals. All dogs bark. Therefore all dogs are mammals. There is no way that a dog could not be mammal because dogs are within things that bark and are mammals.

Friday, March 26, 2010

Vague generalities

Chapter eight has a section called “Vague Generalities” that I found important. The book states a few sentences that use vague words such as almost, many, most, a lot of, some, few, and very few. All of these words provide the reader with only a portion of what the claim is stating if these words are used. We can only assume certain claims if these words are true. To be more accurate there must be words and phrases that are more certain and precise that will leave us no questions on whether the claim is true or false. For example if I said that a lot people will vote in the class, the person hearing this statement might have a different definition of a lot then I do. Making claims and premises we must be careful not to use vague and ambiguous phrases that make the reader uncertain of our ideas.

Monday, March 22, 2010

Learning from Assignment #1

The first assignment that was done by our class was useful in many ways. For my group we examined an opinion article found in the San Jose Mercury News that discussed the problem of high school athletes and how head injuries were dealt pertaining to the athletes. The article discussed in detail the problems that were with the current system on head injuries and made a point of highlighting the flaws of it. The flaws of the system discussed made the current protocol in dealing with head injuries a weak system that was flawed. The author supported their idea that a change needed to be made within the system by stating facts and statistics. The article was a good display of how to argue against a current rule in place by using facts and statistics to support the argument. The assignment not only showed me how to argue correctly, but the article also displayed a well rounded non bias article that showed both sides of the argument. The article also discussed how hard it is for a coach to determine whether or not an athlete was ready to be back on the field. The assignment displayed the correct way to write an unbiased paper that also provided relevant information on how to argue against a current protocol.

Saturday, March 6, 2010

Accepting/Rejecting claim based on personal experience

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BTqgp6jKbqE


The online example I chose to use from the internet is the commercial with NFL QB Brady Quinn and the EAS sports drink. Now in this commercial we see Brady Quinn working out and at the end of his workout he drinks an EAS sports drink and says, “Now I’m done.” This commercial conveys to the consumer that after every workout they should drink this drink so they can “complete” their workout. The commercial does not actually say this but the commercial also conveys that when one drinks this sport drink after their workout they will be as big and strong and Brady Quinn.

Personal experience is one of the concepts discussed in chapter 5. Now from my personal experience I can tell you that one will not get as big and strong as Brady Quinn no matter how much you drink this sport drink. This is a good example of how personal experience is a good determining factor to whether we should believe an advertisement or not. Even though there are famous people that claim that this product works we should not get sucked into the advertising scheme of these companies. Trusting our own experiences and common sense is one of the most reliable sources when accepting or rejecting a claim.